Ed Hooks Acting for Animators

The Illusion of Life and Acting

In an interesting Slate.com article  (“How Does a Pixar Film Get Made”, March 18, 2015), long-time Pixar layout artist Craig Good provides the studio’s definition of animation like this:

“The definition of animation used at Pixar is ‘to bring something to life.‘  If the audience is convinced that a character’s actions are the result of a thought process, then they will see that character as alive.”

Bringing a character to life is an essential first step for performance animation, but Pixar’s definition of animation does not come close to describing how acting works.  “To bring something to life” is what you do when endowing a character with  “the illusion of life”,  just as Frank Thomas and Ollie Johnston explained, in their essential book The Illusion of Life: Disney Animation on page 507:

“…each (character) thinking his own thoughts, and experiencing his own emotions.  That is what makes them so real, and that is what makes them so memorable.  It is also what gives them the astounding illusion of life.”

The Illusion of Life Isn’t Enough

Making a character seem “real” or “alive” is where acting begins, not where it ends.  When animating characters, it is important to remember that acting is doing something and that acting has structure.  A character can have an illusion of life, complete with thinking and vivid emotion, and still be boring.  Example: take a look at ths 3-minute compilation of clips from the Disney film Bolt, featuring Rhino the Hamster.

Most of the sequences display no acting at all, just cute anthropomorphic animals hanging out talking, talking, talking and talking some more.  Rhino exudes personality, energy and emotion; he is overflowing with the illusion of life.  The problem is that emotion is not actable.  Illusion of life is not enough.  The underlying challenge in these clips is that the script is weak. It’s a horribly over-written, dialogue-stuffed screenplay, and even Disney’s talented animators couldn’t save it.


Contrast the weak performance in the Bolt scene to the superb performance in the low-battery Baymax sequence from Big Hero 6.

Both characters – Hiro and Baymax – have been endowed with the illusion of life but, significantly, they are also doing something, namely trying to get Baymax plugged into a re-charging station.  In order for a sequence to be theatrically valid, a character should have a provable objective.  In this case, reaching the re-charging station is provable because the characters will know whether or not they got there.  A character should be playing actions in pursuit of an objective.  Hiro’s actions are to keep Baymax generally on track to the recharging station.  A theatrically valid sequence also requires conflictobstacle, something that the character must overcome in order to achieve his objective.  In this case, Baymax’s low-battery status provides plenty of that because he can barely stand up, let alone navigate home where the recharging station is.

I will depict hatred, but only to show that there is something more valuable.

I will depict a curse to show the joy of liberation from it.

I will depict the boy’s understanding of the girl and the process by which the girl opens her heart to the boy.

In the end, the girl will likely say to the boy: “I love you, Ashitaka.  But I cannot forgive humanity.”

Smiling, the boy will probably say: “That’s all right.  Let’s live together in peace.”

This is the kind of film I want to make.  

Princess Mononoke Planning Memo, Hayao Miyazaki

from his book Starting Point, 1979-1996  

Ed Hooks

Acting For Animators

Ed pioneered Acting for Animators in 1998 while working with the animators at PDI/DreamWorks in northern California. Since then he has presented his masterclass at most major animation studios and game companies internationally. Ed’s book Acting for Animators, now in it’s 3rd edition, is a required text for animators in training everywhere. Ed is a DeTao Master with the Beijing Masters Academy in China and a featured speaker at animation events around the world: FMX in Stuttgart, Germany, Animex in England, Siggraph, the Game Developers Convention and many more.

Read more

Human Anatomy for Animators - drawings by kimsuyeong

Anatomy For Animators 01 – The Human Skeleton and Muscles

Most of us are taught anatomy in at least one class in school (mostly before the frog dissection). Out comes the plastic skeleton on his rickety little trolley base, grinning from ear to ear. But we never really truly remember (or use) the information. We never understand the true nature of basic human anatomy when we sit down to animate. Animators tend to be very much creatures of habit. Sadly if it’s not known, or if the information is not clear enough, (or doesn’t have any drawings) we tend to discard the knowledge faster than trying to animate a one legged horse.

The posts on my blog that have been the most popular have been about anatomy for animators; muscle and bone relationships, and how they apply to animation. For the last four years, I have been trying to merge these into an interesting format with pictures. So when DJ Nicke asked me to write articles for Animation Salvation, I couldn’t refuse!

Human Anatomy For Animators

A series of Articles Exploring Human Anatomy from the Perspective of Animators

The human skeleton is fascinating, since we are one of the very rare animals that stand upright (bipedal), yet we do not have a working tail to balance. Gravity is essentially an enemy to us.

We tend to be more efficient energy wise as we have arms to carry stuff and only two legs that need to be powered to walk. So we have a really interesting, gravity assisted way of walking; and running in a state of perpetual falling and catching ourselves on the next step.

Anatomy study Upper Arm by kimsuyeong

Ok, so now for the dry stuff:

There are six major functions that the human skeleton, the three that we need to know as animators: support, movement, protection (the others are as follows; storage, blood cell production and endocrine regulation). Just to freak you out a little, there are 206 bones on average in the adult human body (most of them in the hands and feet).

Actions of the relation of muscles and bone; we work on a pivot and hinge system bone wise with muscle being essentially a pulley system.

Skeletal muscles are often named after the following characteristics:

  •  Number of origins: Biceps, triceps, and quadriceps indicate two, three, and four origins.

  • Location of origin or insertion: The sternocleidomastoid names the sternum (“sterno”) and clavicle (“cleido”) as its origins and then the mastoid process of the temporal bone as insertion.

  • Location: In addition to its origin or insertion, a muscle name may indicate a nearby bone or body region.

  • Shape: The deltoid (triangular), trapezius (trapezoid) and rhomboideus major (rhomboid) muscles have names that describe their shapes.

  • Direction of muscle fibers: The terms rectus (parallel), transverse (perpendicular), and oblique (at an angle) refer to the direction of the muscle fibers with respect to the midline of the body.

  • Size: Maximus (largest), minimus (smallest), longus (longest), and brevis (shortest) are common suffixes added to muscle names.

  • Action: Terms such as flexor (flex the hinge joint), extensor (extend the hinge joint), abductor (away from the body), and adductor (return to the body) are added as prefixes to muscle names to indicate the kind of movement generated by the muscle.

Why should you take the
skeletal structure into account while animating?

It is the basic structure of any basic living creature and therefore it will only move in accordance to the hinges or the rotators that are put in place to allow the freedom of movement within the confines of gravity.

Ball & Socket Hip Joint

Ball and socket joints: rotate until constrained either by the pelvis or the shoulder blade and clavicle.

Knee Hinge xray

Hinge joints: arc until constrained by the particular end of the joint which locks into place and does not allow over movement.

Cervical Vertebrae

Vertebrae: held in place by sheaths of muscle, keeping the vertebrae in place while allowing the column to pivot.

 So one side is the pulley and the other side is the counter stretch.

Involuntary Muscles

  • Involuntary muscles are muscles that are not controllable consciously, and instead contract due to unconscious impulses sent by the autonomic nervous system or certain specialized cells or hormones.

  • Both smooth muscle and cardiac muscle can be classified as involuntary muscles.

  • Smooth muscle is comprised of spindle-shaped cells that have no striations and is found in numerous locations throughout the human body.

  • Cardiac muscle is striated rather than smooth, and is found only within the walls of the heart.

Skeletal Muscles

Everything else is comprised by what is called skeletal muscle and they are like giant rubber bands with the elastic bands running in what ever direction they need to contract in. So you know when you have stray threads in a piece of clothing? And you pull it and the rest of the fibers get bunched up? That is exactly how muscles work, if they just contracted like rubber bands we would never get them back to a semi normal state.

I have found in observation that
people tend to favor one side of their body in movement

So that side tends to be more developed than the opposite. This tends to mean one side is a little shorter (not by much). You should make sure that you take this into account when capturing life action movement.

Have you played watchdogs (the video game)? If you look closely, (and I had to point this out to a non animator friend of mine) you can see that the run cycle isn’t even. Since it’s all mo capped, the non dominant foot stays on the ground longer than the other, leading to the run cycle cutting off the end of the animation. This results in a very funny non limp in the run cycle. Here is a video where you can see this for yourself:


This concludes our first lesson in Human Anatomy for Animators. Now that we understand how the skeleton and muscles affect the movement of the human body, we can look at those movements in more detail.

Human Anatomy for Animators - drawings by kimsuyeong

Anatomy For Animators 02 – Anatomical Movement

The body is interesting, even in a resting state, as the body doesn’t ever truly stop. There are always subtle movements: shifts of weight, breathing, the unconscious balancing act, conscious feedback of where our limbs are at any given moment, blinking, and thought.

We are going to start with Breathing

To understand breathing, you have to know that gases travel from areas of higher pressure to areas of lower pressure.

Intercostal muscles of the lungs and ribs
  • In the first stage of inspiration (breathing in): the diaphragm contracts and moves down and the intercostals contract. That means the rib cage rises and expands outwards where the diaphragm contracts. The larger volume in the lungs means lower pressure and the air flows in.

  • In expiration (breathing out): the diaphragm and intercostals relax so the rib cage shrinks back to a normal state. This returns the pressure to normal and the air that has been breathed in gets expelled as the lungs return to a normal state.

Intercostal muscles of the lungs and ribs, with Diaphragm

Let’s Move Our Anatomy!

What about movement and locomotion? In order to move, the body has to go from a rested state into movement. That’s when we need to know the four contraction states of muscle. Skeletal muscles are the ones that really concern us and are the muscles that cover the entire skeleton. Without them we could not move and they make up around 50% of our body weight:

  • In concentric contraction, the force generated is sufficient to overcome the resistance, and the muscle shortens as it contracts. This is what most people think of as a muscle contraction.

  • In eccentric contraction, the force generated is insufficient to overcome the external load on the muscle and the muscle fibers lengthen as they contract. An eccentric contraction is used as a means of decelerating a body part or object, or lowering a load gently rather than letting it drop.

  • In isometric contraction, the muscle remains the same length. An example would be holding an object up without moving it; the muscular force precisely matches the load, and no movement results.

  • In isotonic contraction, the tension in the muscle remains constant despite a change in muscle length. This can occur only when a muscle’s maximal force of contraction exceeds the total load on the muscle

We have to be observers and notice things that most people never notice.

As animators we need to observe and pay attention to the movement when there is no movement. We need to observe the distinction between conscious movement, unconscious movement, and movement caused by our anatomy.

Muscles contracting involuntarily, trembling of limbs, air forcing the lungs to expand and contract, the blood pressure in arteries moving the fingers – when we are still our bodies are not, the autonomic systems in place make sure that we stay alive.

The lungs increase in volume, breathing quickens, eyes start moving faster as they blink in anticipation and start focusing where the body will be moving to, muscles contract as the brain informs them that the body will be moving – This is not just for the preparation of an Olympic sprint, but even for the body simply getting out of the chair or starting to walk.

The muscles start contracting from the origin of the moment i.e. the muscles around clavicle and the shoulder drive the action of throwing the ball, the elbow starts engaging as the muscles in the upper arm pull the the hinge up, the tendons start pulling fingers tight around the ball as the they start contracting from their origin behind the elbow, the muscles above shoulder and the clavicle engage even more to pull the the arm straight up. The body has started to slow the breathing as the blood starts flowing faster with the oxygen rich blood, the heart starts to beat quicker to keep up the supply to the muscles that are working. The eyes hold the gaze as the body gets more focused in the activity. Then the muscles engage to throw.

The muscles tremble and spasm slightly as they stop contracting – they have done their job, performed the task that they were asked to by the brain. The body slowly returns to normal heart beat rhythm as the lungs return to the normal breathing rate. The muscles in the face might twitch slightly as the eyes track movement of the ball waiting the indication to move the body into a emotional state depending what the ball does.

Weight, Mass, Momentum

Though it would be interesting to talk about how muscle mass affects the body, now in animation terms you say that mass=weight, and if there is a heavier (i.e. ogre) model it walks slower… right? In real life it is not so straightforward.

Let’s take for example a man with big muscles; he appears to walk slow, right? If we could see his muscles underneath his skin, they are in a contracted state. Muscle contraction happens all the time, but exercise can cause a muscle to stay in its contracted (shortened) state. When it is like this, a muscle will not move freely from contracted to a relaxed state. It looks like the man is stiff in his stride because that is what is happening; the muscles don’t relax and stretch away from the body. That is why he is walking slower; he is more bulky, so the mass is more than the weight in this instance, as muscle weighs more than fat.

What happens if muscle stays in a contracted state? The muscle then stays in a shortened state resulting in loss of range of motion for that particular muscle and can result in changing the way that the body can move.

The man with more fat than muscle has to swing his arms further and moves the torso quicker to get the momentum up to walk. His legs are always trying to catch up underneath the body in smaller steps than normal. The short steps are trying to balance the body mass more than a person of a smaller size. People that carry more weight don’t actually have less muscle, as you might think. They have to carry more weight with every step. It seems like the fat man is walking rather fast; which he is. It is just taking him longer to get anywhere. He needs to expend more energy with each action, mass=weight with the weight of fat being more than the weight of muscle on this person.

The skinny man seems quite fast in movement to the others. He has no real mass (muscle or fat) and is quite skinny. It doesn’t take him long to move as the mass is not constraining his movement as much. Take note of this: if for any reason the muscle outweighs the fat or vice versa, the action would be slower as the muscle has to move the fat and the fat breaks down to feed muscle so therefore the skinnier guy would have a harder time moving if these weren’t equal.

You are probably to the point in your animating that you have have the idea down that timing of the movement has to originate from the torso when moving… legs, arms, torso and the head have to take their direction from driving forces, thinking and balance as well as gravity and physics.

But have you thought that because things weigh more in the body that they will take more time to respond to the movement and the force of the action? Swing your arm around.. and notice that the heavier upper arm even though the movement originates from shoulder will have different timing and different response to the force of movement compared to your very light hand.

Anatomical Animation and Movement

Hopefully that gives you a solid foundation of anatomy for your animation, and an understanding of how your anatomy affects the way you move.

In our next article, we are going to look at the anatomy of walking.